Victory does not come easy. But perseverance pays off. After years of fighting against Mayor Bloomberg and his $1,000 fines on hard-working street vendors, we won. By a final City Council vote of 44-3, the maximum vendor fine for minor offenses was reduced to $500. Lesser fines will also decrease, since the city will now penalize as repeat offenders only those who repeat the same offense.
As Hugh Hogan from the North Star Fund recognized, this was a historic victory for working people and immigrants in New York City. Though we did not get everything we wanted, we won great respect for our unity, advocacy, and tenaciousness. We move toward the future. For now, thanks to everyone who worked so hard to help make this campaign a success.
More than 90% of NYC street vendors are immigrants, so our community has a huge stake in the immigration reform debate currently brewing in Washington. While we may not be in the room with the unions, the chambers of commerce, and the “gang of 8,” we can still have a big presence in the streets. So we have. We marched on Washington last month and rallied at the May Day festivities in NYC with many of our friends and allies. We’ve also talked to many of our members about how not to get scammed by “immigration lawyers” during this hopeful time.
We’ve also been throwing our support behind the exciting bill, introduced by Council Member Danny Dromm, that would give all NYC residents (citizen, green card holder, or nothing at all) the right to vote in municipal elections. This bill would remake the political map in NYC and give a voice to millions (?) of those currently voiceless. Let’s do it!
Good news! While the war continues, we have won a small battle. SVP settled a lawsuit last week that will put $228,000 back in the pockets of hard-working NYC street vendors. Due to a pesky “computer error” that the city apparently didn’t know about (otherwise they would have fixed it on their own, right?) the city was over-charging vendors on tickets for years. We found them out, and checks to vendors (like Mohammed Ali, left, who will be getting $971) are in the mail. Read about it in the NY Post if you like. But don’t think we have won the war — our campaign to permanently Lower the Fines is very much alive. And hopefully it will get a boost with this big victory.
Photo: Robert Miller.
You’d think, with 20,000 or so vendors in New York City, elected officials would listen to us. Sadly that is not the case. They should, but they don’t. Many vendors are not U.S. citizens, so they can’t vote. And vendors are only now being organized into a group to have political power.
In the meantime, we’ll use our other advantages — including the fact that vendors occupy some of the most valuable real estate in the city. Outdoor advertising in NYC is effective — ads on the sides of public telephones alone generate $62 million each year. Starting today, vendors across the city will be using their carts as billboards to encourage Speaker Christine Quinn to call a vote to Lower the Fines. We announced this advertising campaign today outside Penn Station. You can read more about it on Gothamist, Midtown Lunch, and in Metro and El Diario. Keep your eyes out for those signs – and read more about our campaign here.
A week after being branded as terrorists by the fire department, New York vendors are showing their service in the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy, which left millions without power, transport, and food. Vendors, who don’t rely on any power grid, are perfect for such situations.
Jetblue acted quickly, sponsoring eleven food trucks who served more than 25,000 storm victims. Our friends at the NYC Food Truck Association crowd-sourced $27,000 to serve thousands more. All across the city, vendors kept working, providing a beacon of light, warm food, and a little bit of hope in amidst all the bad news.
Its great to see that NYC Council Speaker Christine Quinn wants to support small businesses. Last week she announced five measures that would help undo the “gotcha” culture that pervades at many agencies, including steps to decrease fines for restaurants. Great idea!
But what about small business owners like SVP member Alassane Fall (left), who just got a $1,000 ticket because his table was allegedly one inch too high? All she needs to do is call a vote on two bills (Intros 434 and 435) that have already had a full hearing and already have the support of the majority of City Council Members. Speaker Quinn, we urge you to do so !
Please read more and take action here.
SVP has played an active role these past 6 months in the growing citywide movement against stop and frisk, the controversial NYPD tactic that caused 685,724 people (almost all young black or Latino men) to be stopped, questioned and patted down last year, with no reason to believe they had done anything wrong. Stopping stop and frisk is the first step toward having a police department that treats all people, including vendors, with dignity and respect.
In May, we began working with the Police Reform Organizing Project (PROP) our sister project at UJC who have been building a movement and generating a lot of dialogue on the issue. In June, we sent a contingent to the historic Father’s Day march. And last week, we collaborated with artist Aaron Gach, who developed a project to get vendors talking about stop and frisk with tourists, subverting the dominant narrative they receive about liberty here. We can’t explain it as well as Aaron, so check out this great article in the NY Times!
We know that people who oppose street vendors often do for reasons of race and class. As Daniel Bluestone wrote in his seminal article, the Pushcart Evil, “efforts to curb the pushcart markets went hand in hand with xenophobic Americanization and immigration-restriction campaigns directed at working class immigrants.”
Lately that has been the case in Bay Ridge Brooklyn, a once Italian-American neighborhood that has seen an influx of Arab Americans. While Sammy Kassen’s food cart has been serving up delicious food for nearly four years, lately a few brick and mortar shopkeepers and the local BID have gone to great lengths to remove him. A media firestorm in the quiet neighborhood, fueled by a shoving match, a fake protest by a local bar owner, and some illegal planters placed on the sidewalk to eliminate the vendor. While the brick-and-mortars cry “unfair competition,” its pretty clear the opposition is based on race and ethnicity. SVP is helping out with legal assistance and media support. As we say in this editorial, we hope that, instead of fanning the flames, elected officials can help broker some peace in Bay Ridge.
It feels like we’ve been fighting for a lifetime. But the end might be in sight. Today the City Council will hold a hearing on the two bills we have been working on for nearly 18 months — Intros 434 and 435 — to lower the $1,000 fines vendors still pay for minor violations. It will be a good excuse to release the new report done by John Davis and Alfonso Morales from the University of Wisconsin – Fining The Hand that Feeds You. The report shows that lowering fines will put more money in the City’s pockets, too! And if you are not the reading type, just go and watch this gorgeous new video by Samuel Enblom.
LAist covered the story here. And Hoboken, NJ vendor (and SVP member) Adam Sobel is getting his customers to put pressure on the Mayor through his active Facebook page.